Aug 29, 2018 some of hume s criticisms of the theory of social contracts may be valid, and the idea that all governments actually began in this way is unsupported by the historical evidence, as hume said. He critiques the social contract theory of hobbes and locke, and he offers an alternative, evolutionary account of the origins of government. The social contract theory states that the legitimacy of the government depends on our consent friend, 2015. Lecture 8 social contract theory ubc computer science. Of the original contract college of charleston blogs. This theory draws on several philosophers, who include hobbes, locke, hume. Hume famously argues that social contract theory collapses into a form of utilitarianism. Hume does not seem to have decided whether contract theory fails in principle as the argument i discuss in this paper seems to suggest or only in practice. The social contract theory hume s main claims in of the original contract. The item that rousseau calls a convention is an event, whereas what we call conventions setting aside the irrelevant convention professional gettogether are not events but enduring states of affairs like the conventions. The true distinctiveness of the social contract approach is that justification does not rely on some exogenous reason or truth. Murphy hume and kant on the social contract hume and kant were both political philosophers of remarkable originality, subtlety and profundity. Justification is generated by rational agreement or lack of rejection in t.
The social contract jeanjacques rousseau glossary agreement. The social contract theory humes main claims in of the original contract. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. An essay concerning the true original, extent and end of.
We begin, however, with a few observations on the history of contract theories. Hume sees all governments as the result of a struggle. Many social contract theorists have agreed with this much, and have modified their theories accordingly to accommodate this criticism saying that the. This chapter examines david hume s critique of social contract theory, and particularly john lockes claim that legitimate government gains its legitimacy from the consent of the governed. Many rulers, he pointed out, rule by force, or by succession, not by contract. David hume 1748 edited and rendered into html by jon roland. May unjustly treat people who cannot uphold contract. Dec 28, 2010 david humes famous critique of social contract theory is contained, mainly, in the essay of the original contract, first published in 1748.
I have tried to show that their conflicts, running as they do to the heart of each thinkers moral philosophy, are very deep indeed. Although david hume never produced a single comprehensive work that encapsulated his views on politics, his various writings address a broad range of topics of relevance to political philosophy. Jonathan wolff, hume, bentham, and the social contract. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. Humes critique of the contract theory1 the object of this paper is to put humes criticism of the fashionable theory of the original contract within its proper contexts. In a nutshell, the dispute concerns the theoretical reconstruction of the establishment. The social contract pdf summary jeanjacques rousseau. I will defend the view that his critique of contractarianism can be considered as one of the first attempts to counter a typical enlighteimient confidence in the possibility of.
This paper provides a small summary of social contract theory by hobbes, locke and rousseau. Pdf social contract theory of john locke 19321704 in. Browne social contract theory raises the possibility that the need for social order and certain inherent constraints might provide us with a natural basis for morality. Phil 2, april 12, 2011 hume s opposition to the social contract tradition. Here it is important to stress that hume understands the contract theory to be primarily a theory of allegiance i. Authority and obligation in humes political philosoph cambridge. As no party, in the present age, can well support itself without a philosophical or speculative system of principles annexed to its political or practical one, we accordingly find, that each of the factions into which this nation is divided has reared up a fabric of the former kind, in order to protect and. Social contract theory when we came into contact with other people we entered a society. No other rights are given up, only the right to be a vigilante. David hume, of the original contract, 1752when we consider how nearly equal all men are in their bodily force, and even in their mental powers and faculties, till cultivated by education. He presents the theory that people should have a right to rule themselves directly and not through representatives. David humes famous critique of social contract theory is contained, mainly, in the essay of the original contract, first published in 1748.
Rousseaus social contract is one of the most influential and controversial takes on this vital topic. David hume criticized social contract theory severely. Hume, social contract, and abstraction douglas burnhams site. What objections to the social contract theory does hume raise.
With his calvinist family, young hume faithfully attended services. If nothing else, they show the conceptual dependence of social and political philosophy upon. Pdf summary of social contract theory by hobbes, locke. Summary of social contract theory by hobbes, locke and. Hume s objection to social contract theory duration. Scanlons version, not by the reasons that generate agreement. Hobbes and locke were not the first to use the social contract model as a tool to explain the foundations of human society. Hume and the social contract, the philosophical quarterly 28 1978, pp. Social contract theory has a long and checkered history, and in a future series on the social contract i shall explore some of its important variations.
Contemporary approaches to the social contract stanford. Moreover, hume explicitly takes up and rejects the idea that the legitimacy of government depends on the sort of a social contract or agreement. Humes of the original contract3 contains a wide variety of arguments and subarguments against several forms of social contract theory. Hume delightfully maintains that social contract theory simply fits badly with. Pdf social contract theory by hobbes, locke and rousseau. A social contract is a theory which concerns the processes by which individuals transfer their rights and freedom to a collective governing body such as the state. Humes moral philosophy stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Analysis of the theory of social contract by thomas hobbes. Social contract theory by hobbes, locke and rousseau. Then the paper points out the state of nature according to hobbes, locke and rousseau. A systematic evaluation 109 at its core hume s criticism is about the explication of the normative force of obligations and the theoretical reconstruction of contractarian reasons and humean motives for following normative rules. The notion of a social contract also plays a more or less direct role in various approaches to ethical theory developed in the late 20th and early 21st centuries. Humes indirect engagement with lockes earlier juridical political theory, we can.
Humes criticism of social contract theory hume vs the. Hume s of the original contract 3 contains a wide variety of arguments and subarguments against several forms of social contract theory. Pdf summary of social contract theory by hobbes, locke and. John lockes version of social contract theory is striking in saying that the only right people give up in order to enter into civil society and its benefits is the right to punish other people for violating rights. The idea of a social contract is an important concept in social philosophy. At the very beginning of his essay, hume seems to agree with the social contract idea if it is understood as a thesis about how the very first governments arose in.
Hume, bentham, and the social contract utilitas cambridge. A government can remain in power and be strong so long as it enjoys the support of the people or governs according to the will of the people. An individual dictated what heshe couldcould not do. Here is something that would legitimize a rulers authority. David hume was born david home on april 26, 1711, in edinburgh, scotland. Hume argues that we, as individuals, didnt choose where we are born. He also says that peoples acquiescence does not necessarily give their tacit consent and legitimize government.
Mar 19, 2014 this paper provides a small summary of social contract theory by hobbes, locke and rousseau. Jul 04, 2017 social contract theory before society we were in the state of nature. My intention here is not to exclude the consent of the people from being one just foundation of government where it has place. Pastor fails miserably when interviewed by court about how he spends the ministrys funds. Hume gets only eight of the 948 pages in sabine and kant gets even less only a few references in passing. It also put forth the differences of opinion of these jurists of the state of nature with regard to social contract and lastly. After a discussion of the metaphysical commitments of whigs and tories, respectively, hume spends a great deal of energy arguing that all known states formed from acts of violence conquest, revolution, coup, etc. It discusses what is the social contract theory and the reason. Same problem we saw with kantianism, though phrased in terms of duties instead of rights. Jean jacques rousseau was a french philosopher who gave a new interpretation to thetheory of social contract in his work the social contract and emile. Saying that a just government is a government thats fair to everyone by providing everyone with equal political rights and economic opportunities. Hume raises four main arguments against the social contract theory. Analysis of the theory of social contract by jean jacques rousseau 1. Essays by locke, hume, and rousseau, authorernest sir barker and john g.
The article systematically explores the compatibility of humes political philosophy and contractarianism by reconstructing humes criticism of the idea of a social contract. He expresses the view that in a society man has to completely rely on fellow beings with whom he is also in continuous competition. Part of the useful routledge philosophy guidebook series, aimed at undergraduates. Both are generally relegated to footnotes in comprehensive texts on political theory e. If it were correct, then few would have any such duty, because few ever give genuine and voluntary consent to their governments. Therefore, its unreasonable to think that one gives tacit consent to the government just because they were born there hume 23. Hume, social contract, and abstraction douglas burnhams. I show that, if hume s argument refutes social contract theory, it equally undermines benthams own utilitarian account of political obligation.
Political philosophy social contract moral obligation moral theory political thought. What do you owe a contractor who did unrequested work. David hume didnt buy into the social contract theory of either hobbes or locke. Introduces the relevant elements of hume s epistemology and metaphysics and theory of the passions, followed by extensive discussions of hume s critique of moral rationalism, his account of the virtues, and his theory of moral judgment. The 17th century period was marked by an attempt to erect effective safeguard against violations of natural law by governments. At the very beginning of his essay, hume seems to agree with the social contract idea if it is understood as a thesis about how the very first governments arose in the distant past. The social contract according to john locke confessions of. Arguably, elements of the social contract have existed as long as. John rawls social contract theory agreed with hume that social contract theory never existed but said that it helps us to see what a just government is. Humes critique of locke on contract university press. The idea that legitimate government depends on the consent of the governed was popular among the whigs. In such cases, we dont learn how to make tradeoffs between these conflicting rights. In this lecture i have attempted to survey the main points of contention between hume and kant with respect to their treatment of social or original contract theory.
Therefore, the philosophical underpinnings behind social contract theory are the origin and legitimacy of the government, the origin of the law, the reasons as why to obey the law and how people can punish the government in case they fail to fulfil their functions. David hume was a critic of this historical account, and of social contract theory in general in his essays, moral, political, literary, for example, david hume wrote that the contract, on which government is founded, is said to be the original contract. Pdf social contract theory of john locke 19321704 in the. Among the achievements widely credited to david hume is the refuta tion of the theory that a social contract is necessary for there to be rightful political authority. He pointed out something you might be thinking too. Hume and kant on the social contract 67 seek to refute it. Since men are roughly equal in their natural abilities, there is no way for one person to have power over the rest without their voluntary submission. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. The social contract is one of the most important works by rousseau. The seventeenth and eighteenth centuries are commonly, and accurately, represented as the age of social contract theory. Doubts the adequacy of teh accounts of humes successful refutation of the theory of a social contract. Social contract theorists also discussed which forms of government are legitimate. It asserts that a grave weakness of hume s critique is that he never once addresses the argument on which locke bases his insistence that consent is a necessary and sufficient condition of governmental.
Although john locke social contract theory appears to be perfect in every respect yet lie did not say anything about the legal sovereign. Thomas hobbes legal theory is based on social contract. Social contract theory raises the possibility that the need for social order and. This will enable us to show the inner coherence of humes arguments, but also their pronounced difference from those. The theory of the social contract supposes that our. Law in this period was conceptualized as an instrument for the prevention of autocracy and despotism. The social contract is the agreement among people to live under a system of government, and social contract theory involves how and why this agreement emerged. Even the right to be a vigilante returns to the individual if the. Hume s father, lawyer joseph home, died in 17, and hume s mother, katherine, raised their three children alone. Locke and david hume and jeanjacques rousseau, year1948 contents. According to social contract theorists like hobbes and locke, the obligation to obey the states laws stems from consent to, yes, a social contract. It also put forth the differences of opinion of these jurists of the state of nature with regard to social contract and lastly the critical apprehension of the theory of social contract given by. Under the terms of the traditional social contract theory, then, political obligation is a species of contractual obligation. Case against social contract theory no one signed contract some actions have multiple characterizations.
Social contract was not a willing agreement but the rich stole land and fooled common people into accepting them as rulers. John locke social contract theory study lecture notes. Besides, he fails to understand that revolution is desirable but it is also dangerous and under normal circumstances illegal. If it were correct, then few would have any such duty, because few ever give genuine and voluntary. Thomas hobbes theory of social contract appeared for the first time in leviathan published in the year 1651 during the civil war in britain. Some philosophers have held, for example, that conventional moral principles are justified by the fact that rational, selfinterested persons would agree to observe them because each. But the social contract theorists want more than this. The aim of a social contract theory is to show that members of some society have reason to endorse and comply with the fundamental social rules, laws, institutions, andor principles of that society. The social contract according to john locke confessions. Three figures who put forth ideas on social contracts were thomas hobbes, david hume and. Burke rejected consent as a basis for political authority and obligation. His four arguments include that there is no historical contract that can be traced that established a legitimacy of government.
1027 455 1501 162 203 618 1172 336 1239 1283 125 1552 659 264 1505 229 1338 805 142 454 26 1363 1045 771 72 871 1072 1483 1155 248 1421 743 968 1156 1112 303 1094 623 1057 1094 971